上海大学学报(社会科学版) ›› 2026, Vol. 43 ›› Issue (4): 42-54.

• • 上一篇    下一篇

回到艺术本身:《霸王别姬》的经典化及其海外研究的反思

  

  1. 广州美术学院 视觉文化传播研究中心
  • 出版日期:2026-07-15 发布日期:2026-08-03
  • 作者简介:
    陈林侠,广州美术学院视觉文化传播研究中心主任、教授。研究方向:影视艺术学、影视美学。

Return to the Art Itself: The Canonization of Farewell My Concubine and Reflections on Its Overseas Studies

  1. Visual Culture Communication Research Center, Guangzhou Academy of Fine Arts
  • Online:2026-07-15 Published:2026-08-03

摘要:

海外中国电影学者用文化研究的方式阐释《霸王别姬》,这种做法造成当下语境理论关切与文本实情的错位。基于性别迷失与历史危机、男同性别与身份政治的理论观点,触及了难以解释的文本现象,其中最具代表性的是,小豆子总是唱错、程蝶衣的女性化性征、删除香港信息的结尾。文化研究关于文本的观点被津津乐道地重复,但也似是而非,甚至影响到《霸王别姬》的经典意义。概言之,《霸王别姬》之所以成为中国电影史上一部难能可贵的经典,并非因为其指涉性别意识、身份危机、文化政治等当下社会语境所关心的理论议题。经典电影,首先是艺术层面的经典化;回到艺术本身,才是理解经典电影的正途。

关键词:

Abstract:

Overseas scholars of Chinese cinema often interpret Farewell My Concubine through the lens of cultural studies, resulting in a mismatch between the theoretical concerns of the contemporary context and the textual reality of the film. Theoretical perspectives based on gender confusion and historical crisis, or male homosexuality and identity politics, have inadvertently exposed textual phenomena that are difficult to explain. The most representative examples include Xiao Douzi’s persistent mis-singing of the lyrics, Cheng Dieyi’s feminized traits, and the omission of Hong Kong references in the ending. Although cultural studies perspectives on this text have been widely reiterated, they are often specious, thereby compromising the canonical significance of Farewell My Concubine. In essence, the film has become an invaluable classic in the history of Chinese cinema not because it addresses theoretical issues of contemporary social concern, such as gender consciousness, identity crisis, and cultural politics. Rather, a classic film is, first and foremost, canonized at the artistic level; therefore, returning to the art itself is the rightful path to understanding classic cinema.

Key words:

中图分类号: