上海大学学报(社会科学版) ›› 2020, Vol. 37 ›› Issue (1): 77-93.

• 法学研究 • 上一篇    下一篇

论大陆国家的洋中群岛制度#br# #br#

  

  1. 华东政法大学 国际法学院
  • 出版日期:2020-01-15 发布日期:2020-09-04

On the Regime of Midocean Archipelagos of Continental States

  • Online:2020-01-15 Published:2020-09-04

摘要: 《联合国海洋法公约》第四部分的群岛国制度是对现代国际海洋法的洋中群岛制度的创新。然而,作为“一揽子妥协”产物的《公约》并没有对大陆国家的洋中群岛制度作出明确规定。目前有数个大陆国家在《公约》体系之外为它们的洋中群岛划定直线基线,从而使得这些国家的实践同《公约》第四部分的群岛国制度产生矛盾。这些大陆国家的洋中群岛实践一旦形成习惯国际法,还可能对《公约》的体系造成破坏。相比之下,如果大陆国家以《公约》的群岛国制度为基础比照适用群岛国制度的各项规则,不仅可以实现大陆国家与其他国家的海洋权利之间的平衡,解决大陆国家的洋中群岛实践同《公约》的矛盾,还能最大限度地维护《公约》的权威性和完整性。因此,大陆国家的洋中群岛比照适用《公约》的群岛国制度相比目前某些大陆国家为洋中群岛划定直线基线的实践更具优势和可操作性。

关键词: 洋中群岛, 群岛国制度, 群岛基线, 群岛水域, 比照适用

Abstract:  “Archipelagic States”, as Part IV of the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, is an innovative regime of midocean archipelagos in the development of international maritime law. However, as a “package deal”, the Convention fails to provide a specific regime governing midocean archipelagos of continental States. At present, several continental States still follow traditional practice: applying straight baselines to their midocean archipelagos, which is against the current framework of the Convention. Moreover, if such practice is to become customary international law, it will undermine the entire system of the Convention. In contrast, if continental States choose to apply the regime of “Archipelagic States” of the Convention analogically to their midocean archipelagos, they will not only achieve the balance of maritime interests between continental States and other States, but also guarantee the authority and integrity of the Convention to the maximum. Therefore, the analogical application of the regime of “Archipelagic States” of the Convention to midocean archipelagos of continental States seems to be a better approach than the current practice of applying straight baselines to midocean archipelagos of continental States.

Key words: Key words: midocean archipelagos, the regime of archipelagic States, archipelagic baselines, archipelagic waters, analogical application ,