上海大学学报(社会科学版) ›› 2019, Vol. 36 ›› Issue (3): 1-13.

• 中国问题 •    下一篇

论中国规则下独立担保的功能与定位 ——以利益与风险分配为视角解读《独立保函司法解释》

  

  1. 复旦大学 法学院
  • 收稿日期:2018-06-10 出版日期:2019-05-15 发布日期:2019-05-15

On the Function and Positioning of Independent Guarantee under Chinese Rules: An Interpretation of Provisions of the Supreme People’s Court on Several Issues Concerning the Trial of Independent Guarantee Dispute Cases in the Perspective of Interest and Risk Distribution

  • Received:2018-06-10 Online:2019-05-15 Published:2019-05-15

摘要: 《独立保函司法解释》的出台,正式承认了独立担保在中国国内市场的有效性,并确立了独立担保的中国规则。当事人各方的利益与风险分配机制成为解读这套新规则的关键。独立担保的核心功能是替代押金与保证,就其利益与风险分配机制而言,符合中国民商法的基本原则。其风险虽集中于基础交易中的主债务人身上,但仍属于正常的市场风险。独立担保具有微弱从属性和高度独立性,在中国法律体系中应是一种与“保证”并列的“人的担保”。现阶段,独立保函开立人仅限于银行与非银行金融机构,独立担保的广泛适用性受到了限制。

关键词: 独立保函, 备用信用证, 人的担保

Abstract: The introduction of judicial interpretation of independent guarantees is an official recognition of the effectiveness of independent guarantees in China’s domestic market and a sign of establishing Chinese rules governing independent guarantees. The benefits of the interested parties and risk distribution mechanism have become the key to the interpretation of the new rules. The core function of independent guarantees is to replace deposits and guarantees. As far as interest and distribution mechanism are concerned, it accords with the basic principles of China’s civil and commercial laws. Although risks concentrate on principal debtors in basic transactions, they are still within normal market risks. Independent guarantee is weakly subordinated while highly independent, and should be a kind of “personal guarantee” parallel to “guarantee” in Chinese legal system. At present, the issuers of independent guarantees are limited to banks and nonbank financial institutions, and the wide applicability of independent guarantees is limited.

Key words: personal guarantee, standby letter of credit, independent guarantee