上海大学学报(社会科学版)

• 哲学美学 • 上一篇    下一篇

何为杰作?——美学的首要问题

  

  1. 卢浮宫文化服务部
  • 出版日期:2018-07-15 发布日期:2018-07-15

What is the Masterpiece?——The Primary Problem of Aesthetics

  • Online:2018-07-15 Published:2018-07-15

摘要:

 何为杰作?这是一个被不同时代的美学家、艺术评论家共同探讨的问题。杰作的概念往往在两个方面引起争议:一方面,它总是同完美等概念相关,但每个时代对完美的定义不尽相同,造成了完美的判断标准的缺失;另一方面,杰作的概念最早在浪漫主义时期出现,当时却被定义为是真实存在的作品所无法触及的。“何为杰作”的问题还将我们引向了一个关于美学评判准则的论辩,这个论辩的一方坚持美学评判是主观的、相对主义的,而另一方则认为存在一种客观、普遍的准则。一件作品的美学价值不单基于它们自身的价值,还往往受制于历史、社会等因素。杰作是艺术奥秘的沉默守护者。面对艺术作品,我们应将评判暂时悬置,让感受自然呈现,杰作恰恰就是那些自发地开启我们与美学间关系的作品,它引发多样的阐释,却又挑衅一切描述。

关键词: 艺术评判, 艺术史, 代表作, 杰作, 名作

Abstract:

: “What is a masterpiece?” is discussed by aestheticians and art critics in different times. This concept is often controversial in two aspects: on the one hand, it is always related to the concept of "perfection" changing with time, which leads to the deficiency of the criteria for "perfection". On the other hand, the concept of "masterpiece" was first defined in the Romantic period as something that is beyond the reach of real works. This question also leads us to a debate on aesthetic criteria, some insisting that aesthetic evaluation is subjective and relativistic, while others believing that it is objective and universal. The aesthetic value of a work is not only  based on its own value, but  often subject to historical, social and other factors. Masterpiece is the silent guardian of artistic mystery. In the face of artistic works, we should temporarily suspend the judgment to let the feelings present itself naturally. Masterpiece is precisely the work which spontaneously establishes the relationship between us and aesthetics, which leads to various interpretations and meanwhile provokes all descriptions.
Key words: masterpiece; renowned work; representative work; artistic evaluation; history of art