上海大学学报(社会科学版) ›› 2011, Vol. 18 ›› Issue (2): 107-118.

• 法律学研究 • 上一篇    下一篇

原告住所地与网络 侵权案件的法院管辖

  

  • 收稿日期:2009-01-09 出版日期:2011-03-15 发布日期:2011-03-15

The Jurisdiction in the Case of Network Infringement

  • Received:2009-01-09 Online:2011-03-15 Published:2011-03-15

摘要:

 计算机网络的发达给人们提供了更多的资讯和更加快捷的联系方式,但与此同时,越来越多的网上侵权案件也给我们传统的司法制度提出了一系列新的问题,其中网络侵权案件的民事诉讼管辖便是突出问题之一。依照我国现行法律规定,因侵权行为(包括一般侵权案件和网络侵权案件)提起的诉讼,只能由侵权行为地法院或者被告住所地法院管辖,但网络侵权纠纷具有不同于一般侵权纠纷的特殊性:遭受网络侵权的原告往往难以确定实施网上侵权行为被告的住所地以及侵权行为地点,原告处于起诉困难的窘境。本文认为,应当从计算机网络的特点出发,对传统管辖理论和网络管辖新理论、网络案件侵权行为地以及外国相关的理论进行梳理,尤其是应借鉴美国的“长臂管辖权”理论。原告住所地人民法院应当成为网络侵权案件的管辖权法院之一,这可以给原告更大程度的法院管辖选择权,从而在司法实践中有效地解决网络侵权案件原告“起诉难”问题。

关键词: 网络侵权;法院管辖;被告住所地;侵权行为地;原告住所地

Abstract:

Although the development of computer network supplies people with more information and more efficient contacting, an increasing number of online infringement cases bring forward a series of new questions for China' s traditional justice system, in which the civil jurisdiction of network infringement cases is one of the outstanding problems. According to China' s current laws, the lawsuit over infringement action (including generic infringement cases and network infringement cases) only falls within the jurisdiction of infringement location courts or defendant domicile courts. But, in real life, network infringement disputes reflect a unique phenomenon that is different from that of other infringement disputes, that is, the plaintiffs suffering from network infringement being so difficult to determine the domiciles of online infringement defendants and the specific infringement locations that they are in the dilemma of prosecution. This essay holds that it is necessary to sort out, by way of the features of computer network, the related theories both at home and abroad, whether traditional or new, especially America' s theory of the "longarm jurisdiction" . And the people' s court located in the domicile of plaintiffs should become one of the courts falling within jurisdiction of network infringement, which can give the plaintiff a greater right to choose the jurisdiction of the courts so as to solve effectively the problem of the "difficulty to the plaintiff' s prosecution" in judicial practice.

Key words: network infringement; jurisdiction of the court; domicile of defendant; location of infringement; domicile of plaintiff

中图分类号: