上海大学学报(社会科学版) ›› 2026, Vol. 43 ›› Issue (1): 74-85.

• • 上一篇    下一篇

生成式搜索引擎的认知殖民及其治理建议

  

  1. 上海社会科学院 哲学研究所
  • 出版日期:2026-01-15 发布日期:2026-02-12
  • 作者简介:成素梅,上海社会科学院哲学研究所研究员、 《哲学分析》主编。
    彼利格亚·拜黑提亚,上海社会科学院哲学研究所硕士研究生。
  • 基金资助:
    国家社会科学基金重大项目(24&ZD320)

Cognitive Colonization by Generative Search Engines: Governance Recommendations

  1. Institute of Philosophy, Shanghai Academy of Social Sciences
  • Online:2026-01-15 Published:2026-02-12

摘要: 生成式搜索引擎将人类获取信息的方式从传统搜索引擎的“检索-筛选”方式转向了“问答-生成”方式,这既会带来互联网基础设施的重要变革和人类认知范式的重大转型,也容易使用户无意识地沿着算法铺设的认知轨道滑行,甚至陷入被问答引擎认知殖民的境地。这种认知“外包”极有可能导致“思维异化”,甚至“认知异化”。生成式搜索引擎以大语言
模型为中介来生成答案。大语言模型固有的训练数据“中毒”和“模型幻觉”等缺陷,会造成信息污染,使信息来源均质化,扩散虚假信息,破坏信息生态,陷入碎片化侵权困境,等等。因此,不仅依靠大模型生成的答案并不总是客观可信,而且认知殖民还会加剧安全风险和伦理风险。为了防止这些风险,除了对企业和用户提出更高伦理要求之外,还需要构建“技术-制度-市场-人文”四维联动的一体化治理模式,来确保生成式搜索引擎成为人类认知的普罗米修斯之火,而不是新的洞穴囚禁。

关键词: 问答-生成, 认知殖民, 控制社会, 平庸之恶, 伦理风险, 治理建议, 生成式搜索引擎

Abstract: Generative search engines shift the way humans access information from the traditional retrieval-filtering approach to a“Q&A-generation”model. This will not only bring about a transformation in Internet infrastructure and the human cognitive paradigm but also cause users to slide along the cognitive track laid down by algorithms, potentially succumbing to cognitive colonization. This type of cognitive“outsourcing” is likely to lead to“thinking alienation”or even“cognitive alienation.”Generative search engines utilize Large Language Models (LLMs) as mediators to generate answers. However, the inherent defects of LLMs—such as “poisoned”training data and“model hallucinations”—will aggravate information pollution, homogenize information sources, proliferate misinformation, damage the information ecology, and lead to fragmented infringement. Consequently, answers generated by large models are not always objective or trustworthy, and knowledge colonization can, in turn, exacerbate security and ethical risks. To mitigate these risks, beyond establishing higher ethical requirements for enterprises and users, it is essential to build an integrated governance model encompassing four dimensions: technology, institutions, the market, and human values. This will ensure that generative search engines become the Promethean fire of human cognition, rather than a new form of cave captivity.

Key words: Q&A-generation, cognitive colonization, society of control, the evil of mediocrity, ethical risks, governance recommendations, generative search engines

中图分类号: