上海大学学报(社会科学版) ›› 2022, Vol. 39 ›› Issue (1): 91-104.

• • 上一篇    下一篇

场域性立法背景下#br# 催收非法债务罪的规范构造#br#


  

  1. 西北政法大学 刑事法学院
  • 收稿日期:2021-01-17 出版日期:2022-01-15 发布日期:2022-01-15

Regulatory Construction of the Crime of Collecting Illegal Debts in the Context of Field-based Legislation

  1. School of Criminal Law, Northwest University of Political Science and Law, 
  • Received:2021-01-17 Online:2022-01-15 Published:2022-01-15

摘要:  针对非法讨债领域中多种犯罪行为的危害性特征进行专项立法是制定《刑法修正案(十一)》的重要特征之一。此次修改增设的催收非法债务罪存在行为类型化程度较低,与非法拘禁罪等他罪竞合关系处理思路不明,非法债务界定不明确,与扫黑除恶中套路贷等司法规范性概念存在交叉等制约构成要件识别机能和出罪机制等问题。应以“非法手段催讨非法债务”的场域性特征为基础,基于实质解释立场明确催收非法债务罪的保护法益、非法讨债等构成要件。在犯罪竞合关系处理上,催收非法债务罪与非法侵入他人住宅罪等存在着补充关系、择一关系以及补充与择一关系并存的多种情形,它不仅适用于高利贷案件,而且在套路贷、软暴力等扫黑除恶相关案件中也可以成为规制手段之一。

关键词: 催收非法债务, 高利贷, 行为类型, 软暴力, 非法债务

Abstract:  One of the major features of Amendment (XI) to the Criminal Law of the People’s Republic of China is making targeted legislation on the harmful attributes of various criminal acts in collecting illegal debts. The crime of collecting illegal debts introduced in this revision has the following problems: lack of stereotyped classification of the crime behaviors, confusion in dealing with concurrent relationships with other crimes such as illegal detention, vague definition of illegal debt and conceptual overlapping with other judicial terms like trap loans in the crackdown on gang crimes. All these problems prevent the recognition of key elements and hinder the impunity mechanism. Based on the field characteristics of “collecting illegal debts through illegal means”, this paper clarifies the legal interests of protection against the crime of collecting illegal debts and the key elements constituting the crime from a substantive interpretation. In terms of crime congruence and cooperation, the crime of collecting illegal debts and other crimes like the crime of trespassing on other people’s residence constitute various relationships such as a complementary relationship, an alternative relationship or a combined complementary and alternative relationship. The regulation of collecting illegal debts is not only applicable to usury cases, but also to cases related to the crackdown on the gang crimes like fraud loans and soft violence.

Key words: collecting illegal debts, usury, behavior type, soft violence, illegal debts

中图分类号: