上海大学学报(社会科学版) ›› 2021, Vol. 38 ›› Issue (4): 98-107.

• • 上一篇    下一篇

鉴赏判断及其四契机运用之必然性#br# #br#

  

  1. 山东大学 文艺美学研究中心
  • 收稿日期:2020-04-29 出版日期:2021-07-15 发布日期:2021-07-15

The Judgment of Taste and the Inevitable #br# Application of Its Four Moments#br# #br#

  1. The Center for Literary Theory and Aesthetics, Shandong University
  • Received:2020-04-29 Online:2021-07-15 Published:2021-07-15

摘要: 鉴赏判断的一般形式是“某物是美的”,这是一个先天综合判断,康德鉴赏判断的分析论及演绎就是立足于这一判断。康德为何以及是否有必要运用四契机对鉴赏判断进行分析是一个有争议的问题,“第一批判”可以提供某种启示,但鉴赏判断毕竟不同于逻辑的规定性判断,无论是从现实经验的角度,还是从严格的逻辑学的角度,都不适合把它只视为一个在语言上(无论说出与否)发生的判断,从而对它进行单纯语形或语义上的分析;而且鉴赏判断所真正评判和断言的也不是把某物宣称为美的。它是从鉴赏活动本身的反思中所抽象出来的一个一般判断形式,是这一反思的表象,亦是鉴赏判断本身的概念的表象,因为构成这一判断形式的各要素即表征着鉴赏评判的各方面特征,而四契机所阐明的是鉴赏判断本身的特性。鉴赏判断的四契机就是以鉴赏活动本身为认知对象进而对它的概念进行分析,由此可见四契机运用的必然性。

关键词: 先天综合判断, 好像主观性, 好像客观性, 鉴赏评判, 鉴赏判断

Abstract: The general form of the Judgment of Taste is “something is beautiful”. This is a priori synthetic judgment, which lays foundation for Kant’s analytic and deduction of the Judgment of Taste. Why and whether it is necessary to use the Four Moments to analyze the Judgment of Taste is controversial. “The First Critique” can shed light, but the Judgment of Taste is different from logically determining judgments, thus not suitable to be treated as a judgment that occurs linguistically (whether spoken or not) either from the angle of practical experience or from the perspective of strict logic, nor suitable to be simply analyzed formally or semantically. Moreover, what Judgment of Taste really judges and asserts is not to declare something is beautiful. Rather, it is a general form of judgment abstracted from our reflection on the aesthetic appreciation activity itself and the representation of both the reflection and the concept of Judgment of Taste itself. Because the elements constituting this form of judgment represent the characteristics of all aspects of Judgment of Taste, what the Four Moments illustrate are the characteristics of the Judgment of Taste. The Four Moments of Judgment of Taste are to take the appreciation activity itself as the cognitive object and analyze its concept, from which we can see the application of the Four Moments is inevitable.


Key words:  , a priori synthetic judgment, as if subjectivity, as if objectivity, Judgment of Taste (Geschmack Beurteilung), Judgment of Taste(Geschmacksurtheils)

中图分类号: