上海大学学报(社会科学版) ›› 2020, Vol. 37 ›› Issue (2): 120-127.

• 文艺理论研究 • 上一篇    下一篇

空间转向和塔利的空间批评 

  

  1. 复旦大学中文系
  • 出版日期:2020-03-15 发布日期:2020-04-30

Spatial Turn and Tally’s Spatial Criticism

  • Online:2020-03-15 Published:2020-04-30

摘要:  空间批评可视为空间文学理论、地理批评、社会空间批评、文学地理学等的统称。空间与文学批评发生牵连早有先例,布朗肖的文学空间和巴什拉的空间诗学都是先驱。由此来看罗伯特·塔利的空间文学批评思想,它固然是詹姆逊“认知图绘”理论的一个直传后续,也毋庸置疑见证了人文科学的“空间转向”,即空间问题如何被推向文学和文化研究的前台。塔利表示他和韦斯特法尔的跨学科地理批评方法有分歧,他自己更愿意侧重文学本身。故对于地理或者说空间批评而言,最有成效的方法,是将“真实”空间和“想象”空间,以及读者心目中的地方,交互串联起来。荷马史诗和《旧约》中的“文学地理学”,正可以作如是观。塔利对GIS方法用于人文领域持保守态度,这里关键还是“人文”。塔利新著《地点意识》开篇说,我们谁都知道地图是什么东西,它有什么用处;但是在批评理论和其他方面,地图同样也是一个充满争议的对象。地图如此,空间批评呢?

关键词: 关键词: 空间转向, 塔利, 地理批评, 文学地图学

Abstract: Spatial criticism is a general term for spatial literary theory, geocriticsm, social spatial criticism, literary geography and so on. The connection between space and literary criticism has long witnessed such predecessors as Blanchot’s literary space and Bachelard’s poetics of space. In view of this, Robert Tally Jr.’s thought on spatial literary criticism, inherited and developed from Jameson’s cognitive mapping theory, is without doubt a typical case of  “spatial turn” in humanities, a process of making spatial issues prominent in literary and cultural studies. Tally expressed the idea that his spatial criticism was quite different from Westphal’s interdisciplinary geocriticism and he attached greater importance to literature. For geocriticism or spatial criticism, the most effective way is to interconnect the “real” space, the “imaginative” space and the space in reader’s mind together, as can be examined in Homer’s epics and Old Testament. In addition, Tally holds conservative attitude towards GIS approach to humanities, arguing that “human” is the key to humanities. At the very beginning of his new book Topophrenia, Tally points out that “everyone already knows what a map is and what it is used for, yet the map is also a muchcontested object or metaphor in critical theory and beyond.” A map is viewed in this way, what about spatial criticism?

Key words: Key words: spatial turn, Robert Tally Jr., geocriticism, literary cartography