上海大学学报(社会科学版)

• 传播学研究 • 上一篇    

论杜威和李普曼对“报刊的自由主义理论”之颠覆

  

  1. 上海大学影视艺术技术学院
  • 收稿日期:2010-01-09 出版日期:2011-05-15 发布日期:2011-05-15
  • 基金资助:

    上海市重点学科“传播学”建设项目(S30102)

John Dewey and Walter Lippmann:
A Subversion of the Theory of Press Freedom

  • Received:2010-01-09 Online:2011-05-15 Published:2011-05-15

摘要:

“报刊的自由主义理论”是17世纪中叶至20世纪中叶在西方占主导地位的大众传媒指导理论,这种理论吸收了17世纪西方思想家群落的理论精髓,为在资本主义社会条件下建立和发展相对独立自由的大众传媒体系鸣锣开道。时过境迁,20世纪50年代,西方大众传媒的垄断现实和泛滥的煽情报道已使 “报刊的自由主义理论”显得不合时宜, 1947年哈钦斯委员会倡导的“报刊的社会责任理论”因而决定取而代之。其间,美国实用主义哲学家约翰·杜威和新闻传播理论家沃尔特·李普曼针对“报刊的自由主义理论”的前提和主干进行了有力的理论批判,对这种曾在西方占主导地位的大众传媒理论起到了颠覆作用,为 “报刊的社会责任理论”取代“报刊的自由主义理论”作了铺垫。

关键词: 报刊的自由主义理论, 杜威, 李普曼, 理论批判

Abstract:

John Dewey and Walter Lippmann:
A Subversion of the Theory of Press Freedom(School of FilmTelevision Arts and Technologies, Shanghai University, Shanghai 200072, China)Abstract: The theory of press freedom is a guidance theory of mass media, which held a leading position in western countries from the midseventeenth century to the midtwentieth century. Absorbing the theoretical essence of several western ideologists in the seventeenth century, it prepared the public for developing a free, independent system of mass media under the condition of capitalism. But, as times went, things were different. Up to the fifties of the 20th century, the monopoly reality of the western mass media and the overflowing of emotional news reports made untimed the theory of press freedom. Therefore, it was inevitably replaced by the theory of social responsibility initiated by Commission on Freedom of the Press in 1947. During that time, John Dewey, an American philosopher of pragmatism, and Walter Lippmann, an American theoretician of journalism and communication, have a powerful, theoretical criticism of the premise and contents of the theory of press freedom, which served as a subversion of the predominant western theory of mass media and made good bedding for the replacement of the theory of press freedom with the theory of social responsibility.
 

Key words: the theory of press freedom, John Dewey, Walter Lippmann, theoretical criticism