上海大学学报(社会科学版)

• 文学研究 • 上一篇    下一篇

马克思主义美学的哲学基础及其当代理解——关于“实践存在论美学”论争的论争

  

  1. 辽宁大学文学院
  • 出版日期:2010-01-15 发布日期:2010-01-15
  • 作者简介:作者简介: 宋伟(1957),男,山东长岛人。辽宁大学文学院教授、博士生导师,哲学博士,主要研究方向为马克思主义美学与后现代主义文化理论。
  • 基金资助:

    国家社科基金项目(04BZW003);辽宁省人文社科重点基地A类项目(08JD41)

The Philosophical Basis of Marxist Aesthetics and Its Understanding of the Time——An Argument about the Debate on the "Aesthetics of Practical Existence"

  • Online:2010-01-15 Published:2010-01-15

摘要:

关于“实践存在论”或“实践生存论”的论争,实质上关涉到如何理解马克思主义,以及美学、文学理论研究应该建基于何种马克思哲学基础之上等基本理论问题。在当代语境中,“实践存在论”或“实践生存论”美学致力于在当代哲学思维方式转型的整体背景下打通“实践论转向”与“生存论转向”之间的内在关联。而董学文在“实践存在论”美学论辩中表述的基本立场与观点存在一些重大理论问题与缺陷,明确这一点,有助于祛除长期以来传统形而上学思维方式遮蔽下的对马克思哲学及其美学的误读曲解,从而在当代语境下重新阐释和理解马克思的实践美学观点。在否驳“实践存在论”美学的论辩中,董学文提出所谓的“彻底的一元论的辩证唯物主义”的基本原则或原理,不过是苏联模式的官方正统马克思主义的某种直接复述或再度重申。从本体论层面看,这种彻底的一元论辩证唯物主义关于物质第一性或物质统一性的理论表述,其实质是一种传统的物质实体本体论;从认识论层面看,彻底的一元论辩证唯物主义关于意识是客观物质世界的能动反映的理论表述,其实质是一种主客二分的符合认识论;从价值论层面看,彻底的一元论辩证唯物主义关于真理的客观反映或认识的理论表述,其实质是一种客观中立的科学实证论。而 “实践存在论美学”的提出正是在此语境之下,显示出特有的理论意义与语境内涵。

关键词: 马克思主义美学;美学的哲学基础;实践存在论美学

Abstract:

  In recent years, a debate on "practical ontology" or "practical existence" has been going on in such fields as philosophy, aesthetics and literary theories, thus forming two kinds of clearly oppositional standpoints of actively promoting and firmly opposing, and main representatives including Zhu Liyuan and Dong Xuewen. The debate actually concerns about how to understand the essence of Marxism, and what kind of basis of Marx' s philosophy our aesthetics and literary theories should be based on. In the context of the time, the aesthetics of "practical ontology" or "practical existence" aim at, under the general background of the transformation of philosophical thinking today, getting through the interlinkages between "practice turning" and "existence turning". But Dong Xuewen' s expression of basic standpoints in the aesthetic debate of "practical existence" uncovers his deficiencies in major theoretical issues. Understanding of this point will be helpful in getting rid of misreading of Marx' s philosophy and aesthetics, which is, for a long time, enshrouded by the traditional thinkingway of metaphysics. In this way, we can reinterpret and reunderstand Marx' s practical viewpoint of aesthetics in the text of the time. By denying the aesthetics of "practical existence", Dong Xuewen puts forward his own understanding of Marxist basic principles, which is just a directrepeat or rereiterate of the official, orthodox Marxism of Sovietpattern. It is the thorough monism of dialectical materialism. From the perspective of ontology, its theoretical expression of primary substance or material uniformity, is actually a traditional material substance ontology; and from the perspective of epistemology, its theoretical expression of consciousness being the active reflection of the objective material world, is actually a correspondence epistemology of subjectobject dichotomy; and from the perspective of axiology, its theoretical expression of the objective reflection or recognition of  truth, is actually an objective, neutral, scientific positivism. As an inflexible theoreticalthinking or knowledgepatterns, Marxism of Sovietpattern parasitizes or roots in the tradition of modern metaphysical thought. Therefore,it is a duty for the theoretical scholar to get rid of the dense fog of metaphysics, and go further to get rid of the longterm shroud of Sovietpattern. And "practical existence aesthetics", just in this context, displays a unique theoreticalmeaning and contextualconnotation: really getting rid of the tendency of the practical ontology and the shroud of traditional metaphysics, and opening its theoretical context of postmetaphysics. The theoretical resources and basic ideas are to getting through the linkage in the theoretical horizon between "practical philosophy" and "existential philosophy". In detail, it tries to, between Marx' s practical philosophy and Heidegger' s existential philosophy, establish a sort of domain fusion in dialogue so as to display the implication of the time of "practical turning" and "existential turning" in the context of postmetaphysics.

Key words: Key words: Marxist aesthetics; the philosophical basis of aesthetics; the aesthetics of practical existence

中图分类号: